Loading
 

Preservation Status of e-Resources: A Potential Crisis in Electronic Journal Preservation

Oya Y. Rieger
Associate University Librarian
Digital Scholarship Services
Cornell University

Robert Wolven
Associate University Librarian
Bibliographic Services
and Collection Development
Columbia University

E-journals have replaced the majority of titles formerly produced in paper format. Academic libraries are increasingly dependent on commercially produced, born-digital content that is purchased or licensed. The purpose of this presentation is to share the findings of a 2CUL study that assesses the role of LOCKSS and PORTICO in preserving each institution’s e-journal collections. The 2CUL initiative is a collaboration between Columbia University Library (CUL) and Cornell University Library (CUL) to join forces in providing content, expertise, and services that are impossible to accomplish acting alone.

Although LOCKSS is considered a successful digital preservation initiative, neither of the CULs felt that they fully understood the potential of the system for their own settings and collections. In support of this goal, a joint team was established in November 2010 to investigate various questions to assess how LOCKSS is being deployed and the implications of local practices for both CUL’s preservation frameworks. This study was seen as a high-level investigation to characterize the general landscape and identify further research questions. One of the practical outcomes was a comparative analysis of Portico and LOCKSS preservation coverage for Columbia and Cornell’s serial holdings.  A key finding was that only 15-20% of the e-journal titles in the libraries’ collections are currently preserved by these two initiatives. Further analysis suggests the remaining titles fall into roughly 10 categories, with a variety of strategies needed to ensure their preservation.


http://2cul.org/

Presentation

Trackbacks

  1. [...] of E-Journals February 23, 2012 By Michael Kelley Leave a Comment A recently released study of e-journal preservation at Columbia and Cornell universities revealed that only about 15 percent [...]

  2. [...] article from DigitalShift reports that “a recently released study of e-journal preservation at Columbia and Cornell universities revealed that only about 15 percent [...]

  3. [...] on commercially produced, born-digital content that is purchased or licensed. The purpose of this presentation is to share the findings of a 2CUL study that assesses the role of LOCKSS and PORTICO in preserving [...]

  4. [...] Michael Kelley pointed out what looks like an alarming and growing problem: A recently released study of e-journal preservation at Columbia and Cornell universities revealed that only about 15 percent [...]

  5. [...] de preservering van onze digitale tijdschriften? Cornell University en Columbia University deden gezamenlijk onderzoek en stelden vast dat op dit moment slechts 17% van hun e-journals voor de toekomst is zeker gesteld [...]

  6. SciEng Group Approach to Deaccessioning…

    \\                                         Approach……

  7. […] the recent report by the university libraries at Columbia and Cornell which finds that only “15-20% of the e-journal titles in the libraries’ collections are currently preserved” by libraries’ two leading digital preservation initiatives, LOCKSS and Portico. One […]

Last updated:  Monday, February 6th, 2012