CNI: Coalition for Networked Information

  • About CNI
    • Membership
    • CNI Collaborations
    • Staff
    • Steering Committee
    • CNI Awards
    • History
    • CNI News
  • Program Plan
    • Current Program Plan
    • Program Plan Archive
  • Topics
  • Events & Projects
    • Membership Meetings
    • Workshops & Projects
    • Other Events
    • Event Calendar
  • Resources
    • Publications by CNI Staff
    • Program Plan
    • Pre-Recorded Project Briefing Series
    • Videos & Podcasts
    • Follow CNI
    • Historical Resources
  • Contact Us

Toward a Sustainable Approach to Open Access Publishing and Archiving

Home / Project Briefing Pages / CNI Fall 2013 Project Briefings / Toward a Sustainable Approach to Open Access Publishing and Archiving

November 26, 2013

Rebecca Kennison
Director, Center for Digital Research and Scholarship
Columbia University

Lisa Norberg
Dean of the Library and Academic Information Service
Barnard College

In the 11 years since the Budapest Open Access (OA) Initiative launched what is now known as the “OA movement,” considerable strides have been made toward widespread adoption of the principles of OA. Practice, however, has lagged behind, as both credibility and business models have struggled to gain traction. The transition to OA from subscription-based society publishing operations in humanities and social sciences has been particularly difficult, for reasons that expose the limitations of the current OA models: articles are not the only publication type of value or even the most valued type of publication; external funding for research is minimal or non-existent; these societies consider their publications to be the primary benefit they offer their members and many find it difficult to imagine how they would support their society’s activities if their current publishing operation were to change.

The proposal offered in this briefing tackles head-on the major drawback to the predominant OA business model at the heart of the complaints: that it is based on micropayments made by individuals for only certain types of publication. The alternative model described in this presentation, in contrast, asks tertiary institutions to contribute to systemic support of the research process itself, including its entire scholarly output, whether article, monograph, dataset, conference presentation, or format not yet envisioned. This model looks to societies to play a central, rather than peripheral, role within the scholarly communication ecosystem, and for academic libraries to become true partners with them.

A bold rethinking of the economics of OA, this plan is nevertheless designed to assuage the fears and embrace the investments of the stakeholders in the scholarly communication system. It is intentionally incremental, acknowledging the inherent conservatism of academia. It suggests preservation and curation should be a primary role for libraries, because this is a natural space for libraries to occupy and has always been part of their mission. The alternative model enables societies to have the financial freedom to develop the strategies to provide their members with services that are useful and meaningful. It allows all the partners in the scholarly communication ecosystem to begin to work together to agree on best practices. It provides a clear but ever-evolving and expanding roadmap to address concerns about “free riders.” And just as research and scholarship are increasingly global and collaborative, this plan is not bound by national borders but can be adopted by all those looking for a more equitable and sustainable OA model. This presentation will outline the proposal with the goal of engaging the audience in a conversation about the pros and cons of the proposed model.

http://bit.ly/196l6zA

Presentation (PDF)
Presentation (PDF)

 

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: CNI Fall 2013 Project Briefings, Economic Models, Project Briefing Pages, Publishing, Scholarly Communication
Tagged With: cni2013fall, Project Briefings & Plenary Sessions

Last updated:  Tuesday, December 17th, 2013

 

Contact Us

21 Dupont Circle
Suite 800
Washington, DC, 20036
202.296.5098

Contact us
Copyright © 2023 CNI

  • Copyright Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Site map

Keeping up with CNI

CNI-ANNOUNCE is a low-volume electronic forum used for information about the activities and programs of CNI, and events and documents of interest to the CNI community.
Sign up

Follow CNI

  • View cni.org’s profile on Facebook
  • View cni_org’s profile on Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Vimeo

A joint project